Join me on Facebook as I share book recommendations, insights on reading with your kids, and more!
Mama-Lady Books
  • Home
  • Multicultural Books
    • Barefoot Books
    • Spanish Language Books
    • Other Multicultural Books
  • School Book Fairs
  • Other Events
    • Fundraisers
    • New Teacher Showers
  • Professional Development
  • Building an Anti-Bias Library
  • Blog: Parenting & Teaching Multiculturally
  • Schedule
  • Contact
  • About

A More Complete Understanding 

1/25/2014

14 Comments

 
How much of a difference does it make when you hear both sides of a story?  What impact does that have on your perception of the event?  It can be huge, right?  It can change your opinion of what is right and what is wrong.  It can modify your reaction.  It can alter your response.  

When I became an official blogger for Multicultural Children’s Book Day: Celebrating Diversity in Children's Literature, the thing I was most excited about (besides helping to promote great multicultural books of course!) was being matched with one of the sponsors to review a book.  I found out that I was being connected with Wisdom Tales Press, and I couldn’t wait to see which book I’d be receiving from them!  
 
Well, my package arrived last week.  I tore into it and this was the book inside:
Picture
I have to tell you, I was not a history buff during my school-aged years.  I did not find history very interesting nor important (other than the fact that I'd be tested on it, in which case my type A personality required me to pay attention so that I'd do well on the test!)  Now that I am formally educating our children at home though, I find history fascinating!  I am finally able to put all these fragments of historical accounts into a unified global story.  It's amazing! 

I am always looking for good books that will give us the "other" side of the story in our study of history.  As you know, too often in our American and World history books the accounts are written from a White man or person's point of view.  I want our children to hear the side of women, of religious minorities, and of racial minorities.  I want them to understand the side of the oppressor and the oppressed.  I want them to know that our world and what happens in it is not black and white, cut and dry, but is complex and interconnected.  I don't want them wondering where the people of color are, nor do I want them to see all people of color as either "barbarians" or "savages" as American Indians are too often portrayed in history, or as helpless victims as African Americans are too often portrayed in historical accounts.  I want them to hear the voices of all involved, as often as we can. 

So, Custer's Last Battle: Red Hawk's Account of the Battle of the Little Bighorn came to me as a gift.  The battle of the Little Bighorn, also known as Custer’s Last Stand, was a battle between the Cheyenne and Lakota (or Sioux) tribes and General George Custer and his soldiers along the banks of the Little Bighorn River in Eastern Montana during the American Civil War.  It was a great victory for the Cheyenne and Sioux, but a victory that would unfortunately prove to be the last in their struggle to maintain their freedom and way of life.  In this book, Paul Goble retells the events through a fictionalized character named Red Hawk, a fifteen year old Oglala Sioux.  Goble has taken great care in writing this story so that it reflects the stories that he's read from the accounts told by numerous Native Americans.  The authenticity of this story is solidified by the forward in the book, written by Joe Medicine Crow, whose grandfather was one of Custer's Crow scouts.  At 98 years of age, he has met and talked with many of the survivors of this great battle.  The book also includes a map, a detailed forward, and a resource list in the back for further reading. 

This was a very good book - well written and illustrated in great detail.  It is also an important book, for it tells the "other" side of the story like I want my children, and all children, to know.  Thank you, Wisdom Tales Press! 

For more information on Multicultural Children's Book Day which is on January 27th, please click on the link.  There you will find dozens of book reviews on other great multicultural children's books!  MCCBD is being sponsored by Wisdom Tales Press as I mentioned at the beginning of this post, but also by Lee & Low Books, Chronicle Books, and Susan Daniel Fayad, author of My Grandfather's Masbaha. 

If you'd like to know more about why and how to teach the perspective of the native people of this country, a teaching resource that I highly recommend for ALL teachers and parents is Rethinking Columbus: The Next 500 Years, edited by Bill Bigelow and Bob Peterson.
Picture

"Why rethink Christopher Columbus? Because the Columbus myth is a foundation of children's beliefs about society. Columbus is often a child's first lesson about encounters between different cultures and races. The murky legend of a brave adventurer tells children whose version of history to accept, and whose to ignore." - summary of the book off of the Rethinking Schools website.

Picture
Piggy-backing off of the Columbus theme for a moment, a great book to help children understand the difference between embracing newness or embracing fear of the unknown is Milo and Mysterious Island by Marcus Pfister.  This book starts out with Milo and some of his friends going off to explore a nearby island.  The book then splits into two horizontally, so that you can read what happens when Milo and his fellow explorers are open to learning about a new group of mice, and what happens when they follow their fears.  A very powerful book that leads to great discussions!

To extend the learning about Custer's Last Stand, check out this series of short podcasts by The Little Bighorn Battlefield National Monument: http://www.nps.gov/libi/photosmultimedia/multimedia.htm.  To round out this topic even further, two books that I'd recommend, both written by Joseph Bruchac and published by Lee & Low are:
Picture
Crazy Horse's Vision tells more about Crazy Horse, one of the warrior leaders in the Battle of the Little Bighorn.
Picture
Buffalo Song talks about what was going on with the buffalo population in Montana and the Great Plains during the time.
So starting on this first annual Multicultural Children's Book Day, let's commit to making the conscious effort to seek out and share books that help us and our students understand ourselves, our neighbors, and our history more completely! 
Disclosure: I received Custer's Last Stand from Wisdom Tales Press for the purposes of a review.  The opinions are entirely my own. 
14 Comments
Christine link
1/25/2014 11:02:52 am

Sounds fantastic. I also never enjoyed history until I was out of high school. I had an amazing history professor in College who made history enjoyable and from there, I've discovered, I enjoy history especially in kids books such as these! Thank you for sharing. I tweeted this post and your resources listed are great.
~Christine M.
for The Stanley & Katrina Gang

Reply
Jenna
1/27/2014 06:40:16 am

Who was your history prof? I had this exact experience at Calvin and even considered a history minor because it came alive for the first time.

Reply
Christine link
1/27/2014 07:16:37 am

Oh goodness, his name... Jim Jones. He, of course, states, no relation to the Kool-aid cult. :) As soon as he said he hitchhiked across the Sahara desert (more than once), he had my interest. Seriously. This was at West Chester University, PA. :)

Christine link
1/27/2014 07:16:56 am

Oh goodness, his name... Jim Jones. He, of course, states, no relation to the Kool-aid cult. As soon as he said he hitchhiked across the Sahara desert (more than once), he had my interest. Seriously. This was at West Chester University, PA. :)

Christine link
1/27/2014 07:17:52 am

Jim Jones. He, of course, states, no relation to the cult. As soon as he said he hitchhiked across the Sahara desert (more than once), he had my interest. Seriously. This was at West Chester University, PA.

Christine link
1/27/2014 07:40:19 am

Okay, well the site was telling me it couldn't post my comment, hence the dupes. LOL. :)

Stephanie, a.k.a. Mama-Lady
1/27/2014 10:15:31 am

Thanks, Christine!

Reply
Lisa Nelson link
1/25/2014 10:20:38 pm

I love this review for a few reasons.

1. It's a great review. We definitely need more real stories about Native Americans in our society. Very true! In my opinion, they have sort of disappeared into the background. We talk about them in terms of history but not in terms of the present. This is one culture we don't know enough about.

2. You stated that you didn't really feel that history was important. Well, in order to not repeat it, we must understand, and we must understand the truth. Good for you for teaching your children differently!

Thanks for this. I'm pinning!

Reply
Stephanie, a.k.a. Mama-Lady
1/27/2014 10:18:46 am

Thanks, Lisa! You are so right that too often we talk about Native Americans in the past and not the present. We need to do both if our children are to have an accurate understanding of the various native cultures. Let's keep searching for more great books! :)

Reply
Destiny link
1/26/2014 02:11:17 am

Absolutely agree! Giving children a variety of voices and perspectives is so important. I think that now that we're living in a truly global economy, it's even more important. It helps them learn to be more empathetic and understanding of the actions of others--which are important interpersonal skills.

I also love learning history from children's books. I find it's easier for me to retain.

Reply
PragmaticMom link
1/27/2014 03:25:12 am

Thank you so much for joining us for Multicultural Children's Book Day. I agree with you; it's so important to hear the other side of the story as history is typically written by the victor. I love Paul Goble's beautiful illustrations. I can't wait to read this book!

Reply
Stephanie, a.k.a. Mama-Lady
1/27/2014 10:21:05 am

Thank YOU Mia for inviting me, and more importantly, thank you for creating this fantastic day!

Reply
kristie
1/27/2014 09:41:13 am

I feel like we have so many books that now my requirement in order to buy a book is that it has to have people of color pictures or tell stories of people of color or a teaching tool. Sounds like this book incorporates both of my requirements.

Reply
Martha S link
1/10/2021 05:04:00 am

Thoughtful blog thanks for posting

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Stephanie Kammeraad,
    a.k.a. 
    "Mama-Lady"

    I'm a homeschooling mama of two inquisitive kiddos, ages 13 and 10, and the wife of one creative husband, age 42.  I have a background in Special Education, I love to read, write, teach, cook, and travel with my family, exploring this beautiful world God gave us, and I love sharing great stories with children and the adults who care for them!

    Our family was formed through international adoption, so we are intentional about parenting (and teaching) multiculturally.  I'm excited to share what resources we've found so far that help us do this the best we can!

    Archives

    March 2017
    January 2017
    July 2015
    January 2015
    November 2014
    August 2014
    June 2014
    March 2014
    January 2014
    July 2013

    Categories

    All
    Artist Spotlight
    Arts And Entertainment
    Books
    Toys

    RSS Feed


    I'd sure love it if you LIKED my page!
    (To stay up to date with multicultural book reviews, tips about reading, information about diversity in children's books, sales on select books, resources for your classroom, etc.)

    Mama-Lady Books

    To order any books you read about on this blog, you can click on the link below to go to my affiliate site.  You can feel good knowing that you'll not only be supporting me (a work-at-home mom!) as I receive a small percentage of the sales, but also a really great independent Michigan bookstore, Schuler Books.
    Schulerbooks.com
    Picture
    Picture
    When I first started Mama-Lady Books, I only sold Barefoot Books.  Once I 
     decided to focus on my passion for multicultural children's books, I expanded to include
    books from other publishing companies as well.  But Barefoot Books remains
    close to my heart as it's an outstanding company that creates beautiful and
    meaningful books for children ages birth to age twelve!  Although my focus
    is on the multicultural books that Barefoot publishes, I greatly enjoy the
    others as well.  So do our kids!  If you would like to be a part of this book-loving, book-promoting,
    book-selling community, please contact me for details!  I love what I do,
    and I'd be honored to have you on my team!
Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.